A dog that is kept shut or tied up alone outside and that is only brought out to do a job for the humans – that sounds very much like slavery to me.
On the other side of the coin is too much freedom, and domestic dogs don’t thrive on that either – with no rules and no boundaries. This leads to insecurity.
I like to think of my own dogs ‘captivity’ in terms of that of a child of around seven years of age. The child is dependent upon us for all sorts of things and can’t roam free for his own safety – but we give our children pocket money, love, food and schooling. We try to be fair and we try to understand his needs.
What I love about clicker training and other modern force-free training methods is that it does give dogs some sort of choice, unlike the old dominance methods that expect a dog to comply, with force if necessary, in order to avoid punishment rather than to earn approval.
Here is the story of a dog I went whose life was so boring that it was similar to being in jail – much of the time in solitary confinement.
Theo Stewart, The Dog Lady
Go to the main website: www.dogidog.co.uk